
You wake up a little groggy.
Maybe your legs are still feeling yesterday’s demos. Maybe you’re just hoping that first cup of coffee does its job.
You go through the motions, slowly getting yourself ready for the day… and then you turn on the TV.
And there he is.
Already at full speed.
An analyst mid-rant, leaning forward, voice climbing, hands flying—delivering the hottest take of the day like it’s breaking news. You’ve seen it on ESPN, Fox Sports, Barstool—whether it’s First Take, Undisputed, or whatever show is dominating the timeline that day.
He’s not just sharing an opinion… he’s declaring it. Absolute confidence. Zero hesitation. This isn’t a discussion—it’s a verdict. Something bold enough, loud enough, and just ridiculous enough to grab your attention and carry the sports conversation for the next 48 hours.
And as over-the-top as it is… as dramatic, loud, and sometimes downright ridiculous as those moments can be…
There’s something else happening there that’s easy to overlook.
Because if you strip away the volume…
If you look past the theatrics…
What is that analyst actually doing?
They’re constructing a clear argument. They’re citing relevant evidence to support their claims. They’re analyzing and synthesizing information. They’re organizing ideas for clarity and impact and addressing counterarguments. They’re justifying their reasoning through structured communication.
In other words…
They’re doing exactly the kinds of thinking tasks we say we want students to do when we talk about literacy.
And nobody questions whether it “belongs” in sports.
Nobody stops and says,
“Why are they analyzing?”
“Why are they explaining?”
“Why are they defending their thinking?”
It’s just… part of the culture.
Expected. Valued. Celebrated, even.
And right there, we have something powerful.
A focal point of modern sports culture.
Something familiar.
Something students follow, quote, and argue about themselves.
And yeah… something that fits perfectly in a PE classroom.
⸻
When “Sports Talk” Becomes Something More
The Hot Take Podcast assessment might be one of the best examples of what I mean when I say literacy in PE doesn’t have to look like literacy.
It’s loud.
It’s performative.
It’s energetic.
And at first glance, it might even make you stop and ask,
“Wait… is this really literacy?”
That’s exactly why it works.
Some of the most effective assessments I’ve ever used in my classroom have one thing in common: they’re performative in nature. Students aren’t just completing a task—they’re stepping into a role. An analyst. A commentator. A personality.
And in today’s world, that matters.
The “sports analyst” isn’t just a TV role anymore—it’s a lane students recognize. Whether it’s ESPN, YouTube, TikTok, or podcasts, the idea of having a voice, sharing an opinion, and building an audience isn’t just entertaining… it’s aspirational.
This assessment taps directly into that.
Students grab a partner—or a small group—hit record, and argue away. They debate. They interrupt (respectfully… most of the time). They double down. They react.
And somewhere along the way, something important happens:
It stops feeling like an assignment… and starts feeling like a performance.
And when it comes to recording and editing, the barrier to entry is lower than ever. Tools like Adobe Podcast, along with other student-friendly platforms like GarageBand, WeVideo, or even simple voice memo apps, make it easy for students to capture and polish their work. Most of them require little to no prior experience, which means students can focus more on their ideas and delivery—and less on the tech side of things.
⸻
Where the Literacy Lives
Now here’s where it gets really interesting.
Because this isn’t just fun for the sake of fun. This isn’t just kids “talking sports.”
This is a literacy goldmine.
Let’s go back to those analysts.
What are they actually doing?
They’re making a claim, backing it up with evidence, analyzing what happened and explaining why it matters. They’re responding to opposing viewpoints. They’re defending their reasoning with confidence.
That’s high-level thinking.
That’s literacy.
And the best part?
Students don’t need to be convinced that it matters. They already believe it does.
There’s something about debate that just clicks for so many students. It feels authentic. It feels worthwhile. It feels like something they already do in the real world.
And once that buy-in is there…
Everything else gets easier.
And as a PE teacher, this is where it gets really fun. Because while they’re busy debating, arguing, and performing…
You’re sitting there thinking:
“Look what I just got them to do.”
⸻
And if you’re wondering what this actually sounds like in practice, it can be as simple as giving students a strong prompt and letting them run with it.
Questions like:
-What’s more important for winning: offense or defense?
-What is the “ultimate team sport,” and why?
-Which role is most important on a team? (What sport specific positions)
-What skill has the biggest impact on success in this sport?
-LeBron or Jordan — who’s the GOAT?
-Steph Curry: changed the game or ruined it?
Simple questions.
But the moment students start answering them, they’re building arguments, using evidence, and defending their thinking—just like the analysts they see every day.
Sneaking In the Rest (Without Killing the Vibe)
Here’s where this can go from a great activity… to a really powerful learning experience.
Because while the debate and podcast piece hits speaking and listening hard, there are plenty of opportunities to layer in other forms of literacy without changing the feel of the task.
You just have to be a little strategic.
For example, if students are building an argument, why not give them access to short texts, clips, or data points that support different sides of the claim?
From your perspective, you’re adding reading, analysis, and evidence-based reasoning.
From their perspective?
You’re giving them ammunition.
Same task. Different lens.
You can do the same thing with writing.
Instead of handing out a traditional worksheet that says:
“Write your claim here.”
“Cite your evidence here.”
…give them something that feels like prep.
A quick note sheet.
A debate board.
A “talking points” organizer.
Something that helps them capture their ideas, plan their responses, and organize their thinking before they hit record.
They’re writing.
They’re organizing.
They’re refining their thinking.
But it doesn’t feel like writing in PE.
That’s the difference.
⸻
The Hot Take Podcast is a simple way to turn sports conversations into meaningful learning.
Students take a position, support it with evidence, respond to opposing ideas, and communicate their thinking with purpose.




















